Hopes and Desires / Borrowed Wants

Would you still want it if nobody ever knew

A blunt question that sorts wants faster than almost anything else.

Take something you want and imagine that you get it under one condition: nobody will ever find out. Not your family, not your colleagues, not anyone whose opinion you notice. You will have the thing and the entire experience of having it, but the fact of it will never be visible to another person. Now check whether you still want it, and how much. The question is crude and it does not resolve everything, but it separates a want that is about the experience from a want that is substantially about the standing, and those two are worth telling apart because they behave very differently once satisfied.

There is no shame attached to either answer. Wanting to be well regarded by people you respect is a normal and largely decent human motivation, and pretending otherwise produces a particular kind of dishonesty that fools nobody. The problem is not that status forms part of the picture. The problem is when it forms the whole picture while presenting itself as something else, because then the thing you get will not satisfy the thing you wanted, and you will be left puzzled about why the arrival felt so thin.

The question also works in reverse, which is the more interesting direction. Ask what you would still want if nobody knew, and you tend to surface the quieter items: a particular skill, a particular kind of morning, work that is interesting on the inside regardless of how it reads on the outside. These are usually cheaper than the visible wants and they hold their value better, because their value never depended on an audience in the first place.